How To Interview Management Candidates

Diving into the world of manager interviews can sometimes feel like navigating an intricate maze. You’re not just looking for someone who can deliver on the technical front but also a dynamic leader who can steer the ship with confidence and precision. Welcome to our comprehensive guide, ‘How To Interview Management Candidates,’ where we delve into the art of unearthing the right fit for management roles.

Throughout this guide, you’ll discover a variety of manager interview questions designed to assess a candidate’s ability to lead a team’s professional development, make business goals, manage conflict resolution, and motivate employees. You’ll also gain insights into evaluating project management skills, dealing with direct reports, and identifying those crucial characteristics that set management candidates apart. We know that every management position calls for a unique blend of technical know-how, communication skills, and interpersonal skills, so we’ve tailored our guide to cater to these diverse aspects.

Whether you’re a seasoned recruiter or new to hiring for management positions, this guide will equip you with the tools to discern the cream of the management candidate crop. As you read each section, you’ll discover valuable insights and effective strategies to identify the best manager who will not only understand the nuts and bolts of a management role but also embody the leadership qualities that will inspire their teams to new heights. So, let’s embark on this journey to master the art of interviewing for a management position, setting your company up for success in the process.

How to Prepare for a Management Job Interview

Before you can prepare to interview management candidates for management positions, you need to attract candidates to your position. You can use a free job description template and job advert template to craft job descriptions ready for job board advertising. The job description is an invaluable document, and can later be used as a basis for your job interview and your Manager’s job interview questions.

As a recruiter or Human Resources professional, gearing up to conduct a management interview can often feel like stepping onto a high-stakes chessboard. You’re seeking a strategic thinker, a problem-solver, and a people person, all rolled into one. Preparation starts with a crystal-clear understanding of the role’s requirements and the kind of leader who can thrive within your company’s unique culture and motivate employees. Use these insights to shape a detailed interview plan, from the introductory handshake to the closing conversation.

Review the candidate’s CV in depth, particularly their accomplishments and previous management roles. This will provide a blueprint of their career trajectory and aid in crafting tailored manager interview questions. It’s also important to familiarise yourself with the candidate’s industry background to understand their perspective better and foster more meaningful dialogue.

Interviews are a two-way street, so also be ready to sell your company. Understand what makes your company unique and what might appeal to the prospective new manager. Remember, they’re not just candidates vying for a position; they’re potential managers and loyal employees who could significantly influence your company’s future.

To assist you in interviewing the best candidates, you should take the time to understand what does a management professional do? The best route to completing this task is to review management job descriptions. Example management job descriptions, sample management job descriptions, or a management job advert provide a wealth of information on the job role of a management professional. This begins with a management job summary, followed by management key job responsibilities, management duties, and management tasks. The job description is finished with a management job spec, comprising management skills and management job qualifications.

Management Job Interview Tips

Conducting a management job interview is a bit like being a detective and an ambassador all at once. Here are some tips to make the interview process smoother:

Keep it conversational: Let the interview flow naturally to encourage candid responses.
Use situational questions: These can reveal a lot about a candidate’s problem-solving, leadership skills, and organisational skills.
Listen actively: Don’t just wait for your turn to speak. Show interest in the candidate’s responses and ask probing follow-up questions.
Be transparent: Provide an honest overview of the role, including the challenges and expectations.
Respect their time: Start and finish the interview on time.

Management Interview Techniques

Successful management interview techniques often hinge on the balance between assessing a candidate’s skills and evaluating their potential cultural fit. The most useful interview technique for management roles often involves situational and behavioural questions. These allow you to uncover how a candidate has dealt with past challenges, their conflict resolution with team members and a diverse workforce, and their ability to navigate complex situations.

It can also be beneficial to conduct role-playing scenarios or case studies. These can provide valuable insights into a candidate’s decision-making process and how they would handle real-life situations within your company. Be sure to choose scenarios that reflect the kind of work environment and of challenges they might face in the role.

Lastly, remember that a good interview is a dialogue, not a monologue. Foster a conversational tone, encouraging candidates to ask their own questions. This can give a better idea and offer a glimpse into what they prioritise as a manager and their potential fit within your business. By using these techniques, you can ensure a thorough evaluation of the candidate’s suitability for the role.

Management Interview Questions to Ask

As you prepare to interview a prospective manager, arm yourself with incisive management interview questions that cut through the surface of soft skills and delve into their leadership prowess. Here’s a list of 20 manager interview questions to help you discern their management style, problem-solving skills, and ability to navigate team dynamics:

Can you describe your management style?
How do you motivate team members?
Can you give an example of a goal you achieved as a manager?
How do you handle underperformance within your team?
Can you describe a time when you had to manage conflict within your team?
What do you believe is the most challenging aspect of being a manager?
How have you handled a situation where a team member resisted a change you introduced?
Can you share a situation where you had to make a difficult decision that wasn’t popular with your team?
How do you delegate tasks within your team?
Can you share an example of how you’ve developed an employee’s skills or talents?
How do you give constructive feedback to your team members?
What strategies do you use to manage stress and maintain work-life balance within your team?
Can you give an example of a time when you had to manage a project with tight deadlines?
How do you keep your team members engaged and motivated during challenging times?
Can you share an instance when you used data to make a managerial decision?
How have you navigated a situation where you had to manage up?
What is your approach to onboarding new team members?
How do you handle decision-making when you lack complete information?
Can you describe a time when you had to adjust your leadership style to meet a team member’s needs?
How do you foster a culture of continuous learning within your team?

Management STAR Interview Questions

Using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) in your management interviews can provide invaluable insights into a candidate’s practical skills and experiences. Here are five example manager interview questions that utilise this technique:

Can you tell me about a Situation where you had to manage a difficult team member, the Task you were trying to achieve, the Actions you took and the Result?
Describe a Situation where you had to implement a major change, the Task involved, the Actions you took to manage this change and the Result.
Share a Situation where your team faced a significant challenge, the Task at hand, the Actions you employed to overcome this, and the final Result.
Can you provide an example of a Situation where you had to handle a high-pressure project, the Task you were given, your Actions, and the final Result?
Tell me about a Situation where you had to make a critical decision with limited information, outline the Task, describe the Actions you took and the Result.

How to Address Salary in Management Interviews

The topic of salary can be a bit of a tightrope walk during management interviews. While it’s important to ensure expectations align, you also want to avoid making it the focus of the conversation. From a recruiter’s perspective, it’s best to address the topic openly, but tactfully, to maintain a positive and professional dialogue.

When discussing salary, be clear about the range your company is willing to offer the right person with the right skills, and ensure this reflects the responsibilities and demands of the role. Transparency is crucial in these discussions to ensure both parties are on the same page. However, remember that it’s not just about the numbers. Consider discussing the entire compensation package, including benefits, bonuses, stock options, and other incentives, as this can provide a more holistic view of the company’s offering.

Always treat the applicant with respect and professionalism during these discussions. If a candidate’s salary expectations exceed the budget, don’t dismiss them immediately. Take the time to explain the constraints and possibly explore whether there are other factors that might make the role attractive to them. Remember, salary is just one aspect of a job offer, and other factors like career development, work-life balance, or company culture can also be powerful motivators.

Questions Management Candidates Might Ask Employers

As a prospective manager, it’s just as important for candidates to ask probing questions to get a feel for the company and the role. Here are 25 potential questions candidates may ask:

Can you describe the company culture?
What are the opportunities for professional development?
Can you tell me about the team I would be managing?
How does the company measure performance and reward employees?
What are the company’s long-term goals?
What’s the company’s approach to diversity and inclusion?
How has the company adapted to remote work, if applicable?
How does the company support employee well-being?
What does success look like in this role?
Can you describe a typical day in this role?
How does the company foster innovation?
What are the biggest challenges currently facing the team or department?
What is the company’s policy on flexible working hours?
How is feedback given within the company?
How does this role contribute to the overall company goals?
Who would I report to directly?
How would you describe the company’s leadership style?
What opportunities for advancement are there within the company?
How does the company handle underperformance?
What learning and development opportunities are available?
What is the company’s approach to handling conflicts or disagreements?
What are the expectations for the first 90 days in this role?
What systems or technologies does the company use?
Can you tell me about the company’s onboarding process?
What does the company do to foster a sense of community among employees?

Management Weakness Interview Questions

Unearthing a candidate’s weaknesses can provide key insights into their self-awareness and potential development areas. Here are 10 questions that can help you identify management and team members strengths and weaknesses:

Can you describe a time when you made a mistake as a manager and how you handled it?
What feedback have you received from previous teams that you’ve managed?
Can you share an instance where your decision had a negative impact, and how did you recover from it?
How do you handle stress and high-pressure situations?
How do you react when a team member challenges your decision?
Can you describe a situation where you struggled to meet a deadline? What was the outcome?
What aspects of management do you find most challenging and why?
Can you give an example of a new project or task that didn’t go as planned?
How do you manage your workload when faced with multiple priorities?
Can you describe a time when you struggled to build a relationship with a team member or colleague?

How to Follow Up With Management Candidates After Interviews

Once the management interview concludes, the follow-up process begins – a stage that’s just as crucial in ensuring a positive candidate experience. The key here is to maintain open communication lines between diverse teams, ensuring the candidate isn’t left in the dark, anxiously awaiting news. This not only helps the candidate but also bolsters your company’s reputation as a respectful and considerate employer.

Following the interview, it’s advisable to provide an overview of the next steps, including the decision timeline. This helps set expectations and gives the candidate a sense of when they can anticipate feedback. If there are delays in the process, be proactive in updating the candidate, reassuring them that their application is still being considered.

When it’s time to deliver the decision, whether positive or negative, ensure it’s done with empathy and professionalism. If the candidate was successful, communicate the good news enthusiastically and provide all necessary details about the offer and the next steps. For unsuccessful candidates, provide constructive feedback where possible. This will help them understand the decision and appreciate the learning opportunity. Regardless of the outcome, a thoughtful and considerate follow-up can leave a lasting positive impression of your company.

Management Interview FAQs

Now, we explore the frequently asked questions of the Hiring Team, employers, and job candidates on interview questions and ensuring interview success:

HOW DO I CONDUCT A MANAGEMENT INTERVIEW?

Conducting a management interview requires a blend of thorough preparation and keen insight. Start by understanding the key requirements of the role, then develop a list of relevant questions that address both technical skills and softer managerial competencies. During the interview, provide the candidate with a comprehensive overview of the role and company, then delve into their experience, leadership style, and problem-solving skills.

WHAT QUESTIONS TO ASK IN A MANAGEMENT INTERVIEW?

In a management interview, some pertinent questions could be: ‘Can you describe your leadership style?’, ‘How do you handle conflict within your team?’, ‘Can you give an example of a difficult decision you’ve had to make and its outcome?’, and ‘Tell me about a time you successfully delegated tasks.’ These questions can help you assess their suitability for the role and how they might fit within your organisation’s culture.

WHAT ARE THE COMPETENCY BASED INTERVIEW QUESTIONS FOR PEOPLE MANAGEMENT?

Competency-based interview questions for people management might include: ‘Can you give an example of a time you had to manage poor performance within your team?’, ‘Describe a situation where you successfully motivated your underperforming team member to achieve a goal.’, or ‘Tell me about a time you had to implement a change and how you managed this with your team.’ These questions aim to uncover the candidate’s practical skills and how they have been applied in real-world situations.

HOW DO I PREPARE FOR A MANAGEMENT INTERVIEW?

Preparing for a management interview involves a detailed review of your own managerial skills and experiences. It’s crucial to have clear specific example ready to demonstrate your leadership skills and decision-making process. Research the company and the specific role thoroughly, anticipate likely questions, and be ready to discuss your management style in detail. Reflecting on your achievements and challenges as a manager will also be beneficial.

Quick Links